"An insurance policy may have a good price, but poor value."

- John H. Connors

Insurance Carriers

A Central Insurance Company Natural Catastrophe Insurance Program
1-866-222-2242 1-801-268-2600 Option 2
   
American Collectors Insurance New York Central Mutual
1-800-360-2277 1-888-234-6926
   
American Modern Insurance Group New York State Insurance Fund
1-800-543-2644 1-888-875-5790
   
Countryway Insurance Philadelphia Insurance Companies
1-800-828-6862 1-877-438-7459
   
Erie and Niagara Insurance Association Progressive
716-632-5433 1-800-PROGRESSIVE or 1-800-776-4737
   
Farmers Insurance ShelterPoint Life
1-800-435-7764 1-800-365-4999
   
Foremost Insurance Group Superior Payment Plan, LLC
1-800-527-3907 1-866-856-1112
   
Fulmont Mutual Insurance Group  Safeco
1-518-762-3171  1-800-332-3226
   
Merchants Insurance Group Travelers
1-800-462-1077 1-800-832-7839
   
Mercury Insurance Utica National Insurance Group
1-877-533-6330 1-866-860-1914
   
MetLife Auto & Home USLI
1-800-854-6011 1-800-523-5545
   
Main Street America/National Grange Mutual   
1-877-425-2467